Participation is the input. Health is the output
Physical activity is one of the best-evidenced ways to change health. Most sport and activity programmes still report how many people took part, not what changed for them.
Sport and activity programmes are good at counting people. Attendances, sessions, memberships and participants are reported in every funding return. Those numbers matter, but they describe the input. The reason public money goes into activity is what it does to health, and that is the part most programmes are not measured on.
The evidence is not in doubt
The UK Chief Medical Officers’ physical activity guidelines, published in 2019, say adults should aim for at least 150 minutes of moderate activity a week, or 75 minutes of vigorous activity, with muscle-strengthening activity on at least two days. The infographic that accompanies them sets out what regular activity can do: up to 40% lower risk of type 2 diabetes, up to 35% lower risk of cardiovascular disease, up to 30% lower risk of depression and of falls, up to 25% less joint and back pain, and up to 20% lower risk of colon and breast cancers.
Source: UK Chief Medical Officers’ physical activity guidelines, adults and older adults infographic
The Office for Health Improvement and Disparities says physical activity can help prevent and manage over 20 chronic conditions and diseases. It says physical inactivity is associated with 1 in 6 deaths in the UK and is estimated to cost the UK £7.4 billion a year, including £0.9 billion to the NHS.
The problem is not confined to the UK. The World Health Organization reported in 2024 that 31% of adults worldwide, about 1.8 billion people, did not meet recommended activity levels, and that this is projected to rise to 35% by 2030.
Most of the gain comes from the first steps
The relationship between activity and health is not a straight line. The Chief Medical Officers say the greatest health benefits come from moving from inactive to fairly active, with benefit continuing to rise up to the recommended amount.
A dose-response meta-analysis published in the British Journal of Sports Medicine in 2023, drawing on 94 cohorts and more than 30 million people, found the same shape. Differences in risk were greatest at the low end, between no activity and around 150 minutes of moderate activity a week. At that level, the relative risk of death from any cause was 0.69, roughly 31% lower than for people doing nothing. The authors estimated that 15.7% of premature deaths would have been averted if every insufficiently active person had reached it.
What this means: the health return is concentrated among the people who do least. A programme that adds sessions for people who are already active can raise its participation figures and change very little. A programme that moves inactive people to some regular activity can change a great deal, even if its numbers look smaller.
The NHS already treats activity as treatment
NICE guidance puts exercise inside clinical care. For osteoarthritis, NICE says to offer therapeutic exercise tailored to the person to everyone with the condition. For low back pain, it recommends considering a group exercise programme, and says manual therapy should only be used as part of a treatment package that includes exercise. For less severe depression, group exercise appears in NICE’s table of treatment options, listed ahead of antidepressant medication in the committee’s ordering by clinical and cost effectiveness.
These are health interventions, judged by health outcomes. When activity is delivered by the NHS, nobody would accept attendance as the measure of success. When the same activity is delivered by a leisure trust, a club or a community organisation, attendance is often all that is asked for.
NICE has asked for outcome data for over a decade
NICE guidance on exercise referral schemes, published in 2014, is direct. It says commissioners should not fund exercise referral schemes for people who are sedentary or inactive but otherwise apparently healthy. For people with existing health conditions or risk factors, it says schemes should only be funded if they collect data that meets the essential criteria of the Standard Evaluation Framework: baseline data, follow-up data and process evaluation. It asks for that data to be made available for analysis, monitoring and research.
In practice, that has been hard to achieve. A study in BMC Public Health in 2017 reviewed the evaluations of a set of walking programmes against the same framework and found that its reporting requirements were generally not followed well. The authors argued for checking whether a programme can be evaluated before it starts, not after.
Measuring the output
Measuring health does not mean every community programme needs a clinical trial. It means deciding at the start what change the programme is meant to cause, for whom, and recording it before and after. How many participants were inactive when they joined, and how many are regularly active six months later? Did pain, mobility, mood or wellbeing change on a validated measure? Where people were referred by a clinician, did blood pressure, weight or blood sugar move? Did anyone return to work or need fewer appointments?
Who takes part matters as much as what changes. Because the health gain is largest for people who start from nothing, the share of participants who were inactive at the start is one of the most useful numbers a programme can report. It is also one of the least often collected.
None of this makes participation unimportant. You cannot change health through activity if nobody comes. But participation is the means, and health is the end. Funders, commissioners and providers should agree which one they are paying for.
Our own test for any service is whether anyone’s life changed. For sport and physical activity the evidence says it can, and by a lot. The job now is to measure it, person by person, so that the programmes that change lives can show it, and the ones that only count heads have to.
- DHSC, UK Chief Medical Officers’ physical activity guidelines, September 2019
- DHSC, Physical activity for adults and older adults: text of the infographic
- OHID, Physical activity: applying All Our Health, updated March 2022
- World Health Organization, Nearly 1.8 billion adults at risk of disease from not doing enough physical activity, June 2024
- Garcia L et al., Non-occupational physical activity and risk of cardiovascular disease, cancer and mortality outcomes: a dose-response meta-analysis, British Journal of Sports Medicine, 2023
- NICE, NG226 Osteoarthritis in over 16s: diagnosis and management, October 2022
- NICE, NG59 Low back pain and sciatica in over 16s: assessment and management
- NICE, NG222 Depression in adults: treatment and management, June 2022
- NICE, PH54 Physical activity: exercise referral schemes, September 2014
- Hanson S and Jones A, Missed opportunities in the evaluation of public health interventions: a case study of physical activity programmes, BMC Public Health, 2017
How we made this. We gather official and industry data, analyse it ourselves and write up what we think it means. AI tools help us find sources and draft; every figure is checked by us against the sources listed above. Where we have calculated a share or a change ourselves, the chart or text says so.
More insights.
The high street is a service: what small towns like Beverley and Boroughbridge do that city centres cannot
Market towns and local centres are not smaller versions of city centres. They do a different job for their communities, and councils and BIDs should judge them on footfall, dwell and spend as outcomes of that job.
Data & AIAI in hospitality: what pubs, restaurants, cafés and hotels should use it for
Hospitality uses AI less than almost any other sector, under more cost pressure than most. The opportunity is real, but only if it is judged on staff time, waste and guests, not on the tool.
ResearchPoor health is an economic measure: what the North East shows
Economic inactivity, productivity and local growth are usually treated as economic problems. In the North East of England, the data says they are health outcomes in disguise.
Practical ideas, once a month.
Website, growth and marketing tips for small and growing businesses. No spam, and you can unsubscribe at any time.