The high street is a service: what small towns like Beverley and Boroughbridge do that city centres cannot
Market towns and local centres are not smaller versions of city centres. They do a different job for their communities, and councils and BIDs should judge them on footfall, dwell and spend as outcomes of that job.
Beverley and Boroughbridge are both Yorkshire market towns, and both are a long way from being city centres. On the ONS’s Census 2021 figures, Beverley’s built-up area had 30,930 residents, a medium-sized town. Boroughbridge had 3,070, small enough that the ONS classes it as a minor built-up area, the same band as a village. Hull, its neighbour, had 270,810.
Source: ONS, Towns and cities, characteristics of built-up areas, England and Wales: Census 2021
Beverley’s Saturday and Wednesday markets go back at least to 1293, when the archbishop claimed them by long custom. The two squares still carry the names. Boroughbridge sits beside the A1(M). Neither town will ever compete with Leeds or York for fashion retail. Neither needs to.
National debate about the high street tends to treat every centre as a smaller or larger version of the same thing. The evidence says they are doing different jobs.
The national picture
Savills puts high street vacancy in Great Britain at 13.2% in the second quarter of 2026, falling slowly, against 16.1% in shopping centres. Retail parks, measured by a different provider, sit far lower, at around 4.7%. Footfall is still drifting down. The BRC-Sensormatic monitor recorded high street footfall down 3.0% on the year in September 2026, shopping centres down 3.5% and retail parks down 1.7%.
Source: British Retail Consortium and Sensormatic, October 2026
The ONS reports that 28.8% of retail sales were made online in September 2026. The government’s new high streets strategy, Hope on the High Street, published in October 2026, notes that the figure was 18% in 2019 and 4% in 2008. It also notes that bank and building society branches fell from 21,643 in 1986 to 6,870 in 2024, and that the share of premises empty for more than three years rose from 3.7% in 2015 to more than 5.2% in 2023. Persistent vacancy is below 3% in London and above 8% in the North East.
Pubs are going too. Trade press reporting of British Beer and Pub Association figures in October 2026 said 295 pubs had closed permanently in the first nine months of the year.
Why small centres are different
The strategy’s own typology says 57% of high streets are “everyday” high streets that serve local residents. Their performance follows local population, spending power and access to services. That describes Boroughbridge far better than any city centre model.
The evidence on resilience points the same way. The Institute of Place Management, summarising the High Streets Task Force’s review of footfall for 2020 and 2021, found that large city comparison centres saw the biggest falls and the slowest recovery. By the end of 2021, all district centres and 70% of towns studied were back to pre-pandemic footfall. Multifunctional centres, the ones that offer a wide range of services to the people who live nearby, proved the most resilient. The authors concluded that recovery appeared to be linked to the size of town. That data is now several years old, and we have not found newer published evidence that compares market towns with city centres directly. But it fits what the national figures show.
Centre for Cities, looking at the 63 largest cities and towns in 2025, put it bluntly: a struggling high street is the outcome of a struggling economy, not the other way round. For a big centre, the answer lies in the wider economy and in the size and income of its catchment. For a small town, it lies in whether the high street still provides the things its community needs: a pharmacy, a bank or banking hub, a post office, a café, a GP, a place to meet.
What this means: a city centre is judged as a market. A small town centre should be judged as a service.
What it means for communities
When a city centre loses a store, shoppers go elsewhere in the same city or online. When a market town loses its last bank, its pharmacy or its pub, the people who feel it most are the ones with the fewest alternatives: older residents, people without a car, people on low incomes, and the small businesses that rely on cash and passing trade. Both Beverley and Boroughbridge have a median age of 48 or 49, more than a decade older than Hull or York.
Cash matters more in those places than the national averages suggest. UK Finance found cash made up 8% of payments in 2025, but 49.3 million people still used a cash machine. The Financial Conduct Authority’s access to cash rules, in force since September 2024, mean banks must assess the effect on a community when local cash services change, and residents can ask for an assessment. Cash Access UK opened its 250th banking hub, in Chepstow, in October 2026, after the closure of the town’s last branch. The government has committed to 350 by the end of the Parliament.
The high street also matters for health and for getting around. The strategy cites evidence that people who walk to the high street visit twice as often and spend up to 40% more than those who drive. A centre within walking distance is a reason to leave the house.
Judging a centre on outcomes
If the high street is a service, it should be judged like one. The Institute of Place Management’s 25 priorities for vital and viable centres, built from more than 230 factors, rank “activity”, meaning footfall, opening hours and the evening economy, first. That is the right place to start, but footfall alone is not enough. We would judge a centre on three outcomes.
Footfall: are more people coming in, on ordinary days as well as event days, against the same period last year? Dwell: are they staying long enough to use more than one shop or service? Spend: is more money being spent in local businesses, and by whom: residents, visitors, or both?
The data exists but is patchy and expensive. A West Midlands Combined Authority review in January 2025 found that mobile-derived footfall data cost £8,000 to £10,000 a year to cover one to five areas, that counters rarely provided dwell time, and that several councils would stop monitoring footfall altogether as their contracts expired. London’s High Streets Data Service, set up by the GLA in 2021, shows the alternative: shared spend, footfall and vacancy data for boroughs and BIDs at low cost.
The options
There is no single fix, and the right mix differs between a Beverley and a Boroughbridge. The options available to councils, BIDs, town councils and community groups now include:
Bring empty units back into use. High Street Rental Auctions came into force in December 2024, letting councils auction leases on shops empty for more than 365 days in two years. The government has added £10 million to speed up their use. East Riding of Yorkshire Council consulted in late 2025 on designating every Local Plan retail centre in the county, from Bridlington to Snaith.
Let the community own what matters. The English Devolution and Community Empowerment Act, which received Royal Assent in April 2026, creates a Community Right to Buy, giving local people first refusal on valued assets such as shops and community centres. The strategy adds £65 million to support community ownership. Power to Change found that 90% of vacant high street units are owned by companies, private individuals or councils, so ownership is often the real obstacle.
Fix the buildings. A new £125 million Derelict Buildings Fund targets the worst sites.
Use the rates changes. Retail, hospitality and leisure properties now pay permanently lower business rates multipliers from April 2026, and Small Business Rates Relief thresholds for those properties rise from April 2027. The government says half of all such properties in England will then pay no business rates.
Back the market. The strategy cites Institute of Place Management evidence that markets can lift footfall by 15% to 27%. For towns like Beverley, the market is the original reason the centre exists.
Protect services, not just shops. Use the access to cash rules to request an assessment when a branch or ATM goes. Push for a banking hub. Treat the pharmacy, post office and GP as part of the high street offer.
Build a partnership. The High Streets Task Force found that around 40% of the high streets it studied lacked an effective partnership. A town council, a BID or a traders’ group with a plan and a budget is the first thing most centres need.
Pool the data. Rather than each council buying its own footfall feed, or dropping it, a county or combined authority can buy for all its towns, as London has done.
Use the long-term money where it lands. Pride in Place is investing £5.8 billion in 284 neighbourhoods over a decade, about £20 million each. The government says 79% of places in the first phase plan to spend some of it on town centres and high streets.
What digital infrastructure should look like
A high street that is judged on outcomes needs the connections to measure them and the connections to trade. Ofcom reported that 89% of UK homes could get gigabit-capable broadband in January 2026, and 82% full fibre. In rural areas the figure was 66%, against 93% in urban areas, a gap Ofcom expects to narrow to 86% and 97% by 2029. Project Gigabit contracts in Yorkshire illustrate the pace: in Northern North Yorkshire, 13,440 of 34,490 contracted premises had been built by October 2026. The Shared Rural Network reached its target of 4G coverage across 95% of the UK’s landmass a year early.
In future, we think good digital infrastructure for a small town means four things. Gigabit connections for every business on the high street, not just the homes around it. Reliable mobile coverage in the centre, so card payments and mobile ordering work on market day. Shared, low-cost data on footfall, dwell and spend, bought once for many towns. And a simple, accurate online presence for the town and its businesses, so the people searching from the next village find what is open and when.
The measure
The test we apply to our own work is whether anyone’s life changed, and whether we can show it. For a town like Boroughbridge or Beverley, that means a pensioner who can still get cash without a bus to Harrogate or Hull, a young family who walk into town on a Saturday, a café that stays open, an empty shop that becomes a business. A council or BID that can show more people came, stayed longer and spent more locally, and who those people were, is running the high street as a service. That is what it should be judged on.
- ONS, Towns and cities, characteristics of built-up areas, England and Wales: Census 2021 (dataset), August 2023
- ONS, Towns and cities, characteristics of built-up areas, England and Wales: Census 2021 (article), August 2023
- Victoria County History, A History of the County of York East Riding: Volume 6, Markets and fairs, 1989
- Savills, Spotlight: Shopping centre and high street, Q2 2026, August 2026
- CBRE, UK Retail at a Glance, Q2 2026
- British Retail Consortium, Budget must deliver for shoppers as footfall drops, October 2026
- ONS, Retail sales, Great Britain: September 2026, October 2026
- MHCLG, Hope on the High Street, October 2026
- Restaurant Online, BBPA warns pubs on course to close at rate of one a day this year, October 2026
- Institute of Place Management, Vital and Viable Atherstone, March 2022
- Centre for Cities, Checking out: the varying performance of high streets across the country, July 2025
- UK Finance, UK Payment Markets 2026, August 2026
- Financial Conduct Authority, Access to cash, updated July 2026
- Cash Access UK, Chepstow is our 250th banking hub, October 2026
- West Midlands Combined Authority, Revitalising West Midlands town centres and high streets: footfall data collection, January 2025
- Greater London Authority, High Streets Data Service and Partnership
- MHCLG, High streets to be revitalised with new legal powers, November 2024
- Just Beverley, High Street Rental Auction areas proposed to boost local high streets in the East Riding, November 2025
- MHCLG, English Devolution Bill receives Royal Assent, April 2026
- Power to Change, Community-powered high streets, May 2023
- MHCLG, Business rates multipliers: qualifying retail, hospitality or leisure, March 2026
- Ofcom, Connected Nations update: Spring 2026, May 2026
- Ofcom, Connected Nations: planned network deployments 2026, May 2026
- DSIT, October 2026: premises contracted and built under Project Gigabit contracts
- DSIT, Over 100 mobile masts bring 4G to Britain’s rural communities (Shared Rural Network), December 2025
How we made this. We gather official and industry data, analyse it ourselves and write up what we think it means. AI tools help us find sources and draft; every figure is checked by us against the sources listed above. Where we have calculated a share or a change ourselves, the chart or text says so.
More insights.
AI in hospitality: what pubs, restaurants, cafés and hotels should use it for
Hospitality uses AI less than almost any other sector, under more cost pressure than most. The opportunity is real, but only if it is judged on staff time, waste and guests, not on the tool.
ResearchPoor health is an economic measure: what the North East shows
Economic inactivity, productivity and local growth are usually treated as economic problems. In the North East of England, the data says they are health outcomes in disguise.
ResearchLeisure centres are health infrastructure: fund them on health outcomes, not memberships
Public leisure centres prevent illness, support people back from cancer and reach the places with the poorest health. They are still funded and judged as if they were gyms.
Practical ideas, once a month.
Website, growth and marketing tips for small and growing businesses. No spam, and you can unsubscribe at any time.