Self-referral and self-pay: what the NHS and private health providers can learn from each other about access
More patients are walking into care without a GP referral, through NHS self-referral or by paying. Each side has solved part of the access problem the other is still struggling with.
For most of its history the NHS has had one front door for planned care: the GP. That is changing from two directions at once. The NHS is opening more routes in through self-referral. At the same time, more people are buying their way in.
Healthwatch England’s polling with Savanta, carried out in late 2025, found that 16% of adults in England had used private health services in the past year, up from 9% in 2023. Among those who did, 39% said long NHS waits were the main reason. The Private Healthcare Information Network reported that self-pay admissions to private hospitals rose 7.7% in January to March 2026, to the highest level it has recorded.
Both trends say the same thing about what patients want: a faster, more direct route to someone who can help. Each side of the system has got part of that right.
What the NHS has learned about self-referral
NHS self-referral is not new, but it has grown. NHS England’s 2023 plan for recovering access to primary care expanded self-referral to community musculoskeletal services, audiology for older people, weight management, community podiatry, and wheelchair and community equipment services. At the time, more than 30,000 people a month were already referring themselves. The 10 Year Health Plan, published in July 2025, goes further: through the NHS App, patients will be able to self-refer to talking therapies, MSK services, podiatry and audiology from the outset.
The largest established example is NHS Talking Therapies. Anyone can self-refer online without seeing a GP. In 2025-26 the service received 1.81 million referrals, 674,683 people completed a course of treatment, and 50.1% of those moved to recovery. Some 89.1% started treatment within six weeks. It is one of the few NHS services that publishes an outcome measure alongside its activity, and it shows that direct access and measured results can go together.
But self-referral only shortens the route if there is capacity at the end of it. Healthwatch Wirral surveyed 90 people who had used a new MSK self-referral route. Most found referring easy. Only 41 of them, 45.6%, had been given an appointment by the time they were asked. The Chartered Society of Physiotherapy, which has long argued for self-referral, makes the same point about workforce: direct access cannot be delivered consistently without the staff to support it.
What this means: a front door that opens onto the same queue is not faster access. It just moves the wait.
What private providers have learned about access
Private providers have built their model on the thing NHS patients find hardest: a quick, predictable route from first contact to an appointment, with a clear price and a clear next step. PHIN’s data shows where that appeals most. Cataract surgery accounted for 46% of the increase in self-pay admissions in early 2026, with self-pay cataract admissions up 21%. Older patients, facing a common procedure with a predictable outcome, are choosing to pay rather than wait.
Source: PHIN, Private healthcare market update, September 2026
Self-pay demand is not a straight line, though. PHIN found that self-pay admissions across 2025 as a whole were up just 0.2% on 2024, before the record first quarter of 2026. The market responds quickly to NHS waits and to household budgets.
Where private access falls short
Private access is fast for those who can pay, and that is the problem. Healthwatch found that 10% of people earning under £20,000 had used private care in the past year, against 35% of those earning £80,000 or more. The Nuffield Trust warned in 2024 that the balance of care is very slowly shifting from need towards ability to pay.
Source: Healthwatch England, Two-tier healthcare increases as confidence in timely access remains low, March 2026
Private providers also see only the part of the pathway they are paid for. A self-pay patient may get a fast cataract operation but return to the NHS for everything around it. And the independent sector’s share of NHS-funded elective care has fallen, from a peak of around 10% to 7.5% in February 2026, according to the Independent Healthcare Providers Network, as integrated care boards have tightened control of activity plans. The capacity exists, but it is not consistently used to shorten NHS waits.
What each side could take from the other
From private providers, the NHS could take the discipline of the front door: a clear promise about when a patient will be seen, a booking at the point of contact rather than a referral into a queue, and plain information about what happens next. Self-referral that ends in an appointment date, not just an acknowledgement, would close the gap Healthwatch Wirral found.
From the NHS, private providers could take two things. The first is outcome measurement. Talking Therapies reports recovery for every completed course. Few private services publish anything comparable for self-pay patients. The second is reach. The 10 Year Health Plan says self-referral must work for everyone, not just the most confident and health literate. A provider that wants NHS contracts, or a fair reputation, should be able to show who it serves as well as how fast.
For both, the useful measure is the same: the time from a patient first asking for help to getting it, split by who they are.
What we would count
For any service that offers self-referral or self-pay, we would ask four questions. How long from first contact to a booked appointment, not just to an acknowledgement? How long to an answer or a plan? What changed for the patient, measured before and after? And who is using the route: does it reach people in the most deprived areas, older people and those without digital access, or only people who would have got through anyway?
The test we apply to our own work is whether anyone’s life changed, and whether we can show it. A front door is only as good as what lies behind it. A route into care that gets people seen sooner, gets them better and reaches those who used to wait longest is changing lives. One that only moves the queue, or moves it only for those who can pay, is not.
- Healthwatch England, Two-tier healthcare increases as confidence in timely access remains low, March 2026
- PHIN, Private healthcare market update: September 2026, United Kingdom
- PHIN, Record level of self-pay at private hospitals driven by older patients, September 2026
- PHIN, Private healthcare market update: June 2026, United Kingdom
- NHS England, Delivery plan for recovering access to primary care, May 2023
- DHSC, Fit for the future: 10 Year Health Plan for England, July 2025
- NHS England, NHS Talking Therapies for anxiety and depression, annual report 2025-26, September 2026
- NHS England, NHS launches major campaign to support millions more people with anxiety, February 2026
- Healthwatch Wirral, Musculoskeletal self-referral pathway review, January 2026
- Chartered Society of Physiotherapy, Self-referral and primary care announcement, June 2023
- Nuffield Trust, Patients drift towards paying for hospital care out of their own pocket across all four UK countries, May 2024
- Independent Healthcare Providers Network, NHS electives insight, April 2026
How we made this. We gather official and industry data, analyse it ourselves and write up what we think it means. AI tools help us find sources and draft; every figure is checked by us against the sources listed above. Where we have calculated a share or a change ourselves, the chart or text says so.
More insights.
The high street is a service: what small towns like Beverley and Boroughbridge do that city centres cannot
Market towns and local centres are not smaller versions of city centres. They do a different job for their communities, and councils and BIDs should judge them on footfall, dwell and spend as outcomes of that job.
Data & AIAI in hospitality: what pubs, restaurants, cafés and hotels should use it for
Hospitality uses AI less than almost any other sector, under more cost pressure than most. The opportunity is real, but only if it is judged on staff time, waste and guests, not on the tool.
ResearchPoor health is an economic measure: what the North East shows
Economic inactivity, productivity and local growth are usually treated as economic problems. In the North East of England, the data says they are health outcomes in disguise.
Practical ideas, once a month.
Website, growth and marketing tips for small and growing businesses. No spam, and you can unsubscribe at any time.